An Overview of Testing Options for dbt (data build tool)

dbt, also known as data build tool, is a data transformation framework that leverages templated SQL to transform and test data. dbt is part of the modern data stack and helps practitioners apply software development best practices on data pipelines. Some of these best practices include code modularity, version control, and continuous testing via its built in data quality framework. In this article we will focus on how data can be tested with dbt via build in functionality and with additional dbt packages and libraries.

Adding tests to workflows does more than ensure code and data integrity; it facilitates a continuous dialogue with your data, enhancing understanding and responsiveness. By integrating testing into your regular workflows, you can:

• Identify Specific Issues: Tests can direct your attention to specific records that may require closer inspection or immediate action. This targeted approach helps maintain high data quality and reliability.
• Enhance Data Familiarization: Regular interaction with test results promotes a deeper understanding of the data's characteristics and behaviors. This ongoing learning process can inform better decision-making and data handling practices.
• Maintain Active Engagement: Incorporating tests as a routine part of your workflow turns data testing from a periodic audit into a consistent part of your data management strategy. This active engagement helps in preemptively identifying potential discrepancies before they escalate into larger issues.

By embedding testing into the development cycle and consuming the results diligently, teams not only safeguard the functionality of their data transformations but also enhance their overall data literacy and operational efficiency. This proactive approach to testing ensures that the insights derived from data are both accurate and actionable.

dbt tests in dbt Core

In dbt, there are two main categories of tests: data tests and unit tests.

Data tests are meant to be executed with every pipeline run to validate the integrity of the data and can be further divided into two types: Generic tests and Singular tests.

• Singular Tests: A singular dbt test is written in a SQL file with a query that returns records that fail the test. This type of test is straightforward and focuses on specific conditions or rules that data must meet.
• Generic Tests: A generic dbt test is defined in a YAML file and references a macro that contains the SQL logic. This setup allows for greater flexibility and reuse. A dbt test macro typically contains a select statement that returns records that don’t pass the test. The macro takes a model and column_name to be injected with Jinja templates, and extra arguments can be passed when configuring the test. This configurability makes generic tests versatile and adaptable to various scenarios, enhancing the robustness of your data testing framework.

Regardless of the type of data test, the process is the same behind the scenes: dbt will compile the code to a SQL SELECT statement and execute it against your database. If any rows are returned by the query, this indicates a failure to dbt.

Unit tests, on the other hand, are meant to validate your transformation logic. They rely on predefined data for comparison to ensure your logic is returning an expected result. Unlike data tests, which are meant to be run with every pipeline execution, unit tests are typically run during the CI (Continuous Integration) step when new code is introduced. Unit tests were incorporated in dbt Core as of version 1.8.

‍

dbt Core Generic tests

These are foundational tests provided by dbt-core, focusing on basic schema validation and source freshness. These tests are ideal for ensuring that your data sources remain valid and up-to-date.

dbt-core provides four built-in generic tests that are essential for data modeling and ensuring data integrity:

unique: is a test to verify that every value in a column (e.g. customer_id) contains unique values. This is useful for finding records that may inadvertently be duplicated in your data.

not_null: is a test to check that the values for a given column are always present. This can help you find cases where data in a column suddenly arrives without being populated.

accepted_values: this test is used to validate whether a set of values within a column is present. For example, in a column called payment_status, there can be values like pending, failed, accepted, rejected, etc. This test is used to verify that each row within the column contains one of the different payment statuses, but no other. This is useful to detect changes in the data like when a value gets changed such as accepted being replaced with approved.

relationships: these tests check referential integrity. This type of test is useful when you have related columns (e.g. the customer identifier) in two different tables. One table serves as the “parent” and the other is the “child” table. This is common when one table has a transaction and only lists a customer_id and the other table has the details for that customer. With this test we can verify that every row in the transaction table has a corresponding record in the dimension/details table. For example, if you have orders for customer_ids 1, 2, 3 we can validate that we have information about each of these customers in the customer details table.

Using a generic test is done by adding it to the model's property (yml) file.

Generic tests can accept additional test configurations such as a where clause to apply the test on a subset of rows. This can be useful on large tables by limiting the test to recent data or excluding rows based on the value of another column. Since an error will stop a dbt build or dbt test of the project, it is also possible to assign a severity to a test and optionally a threshold where errors will be treated as warning instead of errors. Finally, since dbt will automatically generate a name for the test, it may be useful to override the auto generated test name for simplicity. Here's the same property file from above with the additional configurations defined.

dbt Core singular tests

Singular tests allow for the customization of testing parameters to create tailored tests when the default generic ones (or the ones in the packages discussed below) do not meet your needs. These tests are simple SQL queries that express assertions about your data. An example of this type of test can be a more complex assertion such as having sales for one product be within +/- 10% of another product. The SQL simply needs to return the rows that do not meet this condition.

dbt Core custom generic tests

In dbt, it is also possible to define your own custom generic tests. This may be useful when you find yourself creating similar Singular tests. A custom generic test is essentially the same as a dbt macro which has a least a model as a parameter, and optionally column_name, if the test will apply to a column. Once the generic test is defined, it can be applied many times just like the generic tests shipped with dbt Core. It is also possible to pass additional parameters to a custom generic test.

dbt Core unit testing

As our data transformations become more complex, the need for testing becomes increasingly important. The concept of unit testing is already well established in software development, where tests confirm that individual units of code work as intended. Recognizing this, dbt 1.8 introduced unit testing.

Unlike the data tests we have above, which ensure that incoming data meets specific criteria and are run at every data refresh, unit tests are designed to verify that the transformation logic itself produces the expected results. In the context of dbt, unit tests validate transformation logic by comparing the test results against predefined data typically defined using seeds (CSV files) or SQL queries. Unit tests should only be executed when new data transformation code is introduced and implemented since they are designed to help catch potential issues early in the development process. It is recommended to run unit tests only during the CI step. Running them in production would be a redundant use of compute resources because the expected outcomes do not change. Unit testing is only available in 1.8 or higher, but there are community packages (dbt-unit-testing, dbt_datamocktool, dbt-unittest) that have worked to solve this problem and are worth exploring if you are not using dbt 1.8.

dbt Core freshness check

While not technically a dbt test, a freshness check validates the timeliness of source data. The freshness check in dbt Core is designed to monitor the timeliness of the data. It helps ensure that the data loaded into your warehouse is updated regularly and remains relevant for decision-making processes. This is valuable because sometimes data will stop getting refreshed and the data pipelines will continue to run with a silent failure. To assure that you are alerted when a data delivery SLA is not met, simply add a freshness check to your sources.

This comprehensive suite of testing capabilities in dbt Core ensures that data teams can build, maintain, and verify the reliability and accuracy of their data models effectively.

Popular dbt Testing Packages

In addition to the generic tests that can be found within dbt Core, there are a lot more in the dbt ecosystem. These tests are found in dbt packages. Packages are libraries of reusable SQL code created by organizations of the dbt community. We will briefly go over some of the tests that can be found in these packages.

dbt-utils generic dbt tests

The dbt-utils package, created by dbt Labs, contains generic dbt tests, SQL generators, and macros. The dbt_utils package include 16 generic tests including:

not_accepted_values: this test is the opposite of the accepted_values test and is used to check that specific values are NOT present in a particular range of rows.‍

equal_rowcount: this test checks that two different tables have the same number of rows. This is a useful test that can assure that a transformation step does not accidentally introduce additional rows in the target table.‍

fewer_rows_than: this test is used to verify that a target table contains fewer rows than a source table. For example, if you are aggregating a table, you expect that the target table will have fewer rows than the table you are aggregating. This test can help you validate this condition.

There are 17 generic dbt tests available in the dbt-utils package.‍

dbt-expectations generic dbt tests

Another awesome package that can accelerate your data testing is dbt-expectations. This package is a port of the great Python library Great Expectations. For those not familiar, Great Expectations is an open-source Python library that is used for automated testing. dbt-expectations is modeled after this library and was developed by Calogica so dbt practitioners would have access to an additional set of pre-created Generic tests without adding another tool to the data platform. Tests in dbt-expectations are divided into seven categories encompassing a total of 62 generic dbt tests:

• Table shape (15 generic dbt tests)‍
• Missing values, unique values, and types (6 generic dbt tests)
• ‍Sets and ranges (5 generic dbt tests)
• ‍String matching (10 generic dbt tests)
• ‍Aggregate functions(17 generic dbt tests)‍
• Multi-column (6 generic dbt tests)‍
• Distributional functions (3 generic dbt tests)

You can find detailed information on all the dbt-expectations generics tests in their documentation.

dbt_constraints

Created by Snowflake, dbt_constraints adds primary and foreign key constraints to dbt models. When incorporated into a dbt project, this package automatically creates unique keys for all existing unique and dbt_utils.unique_combination_of_columns tests, along with foreign keys for existing relationship tests and not null constraints for not_null tests. It provides three flexible tests - primary_key, unique_key, and foreign_key - which can be used inline, out-of-line, and support multiple columns.

elementary dbt-data-reliabilit generic dbt tests

The elementary tool offers 10 generic dbt tests that help in detecting schema changes, validating JSON schemas, and monitoring anomalies in source freshness, among other functionalities.

dbt-fihr generic dbt tests

dbt-fihr focuses on the healthcare sector, providing 20 generic dbt tests for validating HL7® FHIR® (Fast Healthcare Interoperability Resources) data types, a standard for exchanging healthcare information across different systems.

fhir-dbt-analytics generic dbt tests

Maintained by Google, the fhir-dbt-analytics package includes tests that ensure the quality of clinical data. These tests might involve counting the number of FHIR resources to verify expected counts or checking references between FHIR resources.

By leveraging these diverse dbt testing packages, data teams can significantly enhance their data validation processes, ensuring that their data pipelines are robust, accurate, and reliable.

dbt testing during development

While the tests above run against production data and are run even when none of the dbt code has changed, there are some tests that should be applied during development. This will improve a project's long term maintainability, assure project governance, and validate transformation logic in isolation of production data.

dbt-checkpoint

dbt-checkpoint is a library that can be leveraged during the development and release life-cycle to assure a level of governance of the dbt project. Typical validations include assuring that dbt models and/or their columns have descriptions and that all the columns in a dbt model (sql) are present in a property file (yml).

dbt-meta-testing

This dbt-meta-testing package contains macros to assert test and documentation coverage leveraging a configuration defined in the dbt_project.yml configuration settings.

dbt-unit-testing (dbt 1.8 has built in unit testing)

While dbt tests are great to test with "real" data, sometimes you may want to test the logic of a transformation with "fake" data. This type of test is called a unit test. The dbt-unit-testing package has all you need to do proper dbt unit testing. (side note, the dbt Core team has announced the unit testing will be part of a future release of dbt although it may not be exactly as done using this package).

dbt_datamocktool

dbt_datamocktool can be used to create mock CSV seeds to stand in for the sources and refs that your models use and test that the model produces the expected output as compared with another CSV seed.

dbt-unittest (dbt 1.8 has built in unit testing)

The dbt-unittest is a dbt package to enhance dbt package development by providing unit testing macros.

Reporting results of dbt tests

By default, dbt will not store the results of a dbt test execution. There is a configuration that can be set for the dbt project or at the specific model level which will have dbt store the failures of the test in a table in the data warehouse. While this is a good start, these test results get overridden each time dbt tests are run. To overcome this deficiency, tools have been developed in the community that store results longitudinally and even provide dashboards of test results.

Elementary

Elementary is an open source data observability tool for dbt. It simplifies the capture of dbt test results over time, enables testing without having to manually add tests to all your dbt model columns, and has a user interface for viewing test results as well as dbt lineage.

Elementary also provides advanced configurations for generating Slack alerts for dbt tests, enhancing how teams monitor and respond to data quality issues. You can configure alerts based on test results, test statuses, and test durations. Additionally, you can set up recurring alerts based on a schedule that you define, ensuring continuous oversight without constant manual checking.

Key features include:

• Custom Channel: Direct alerts to specific Slack channels or users, making sure the right team members receive updates in real time.
• Suppression Interval: Decide how often to send alerts by setting suppression intervals, which prevent alert overload by spacing notifications according to your specified time frame.
• Alert Fields: Customize the content of each alert with specific test details, providing immediate insight into the nature and urgency of the issue.
• More Options: Tailor messages that are sent in alerts, integrating them seamlessly into your team’s communication flow.

This comprehensive suite of tools not only sends notifications but also allows for significant customization, ensuring that alerts are meaningful and actionable. The integration of these features into your workflow facilitates better data management and quicker response to potential data discrepancies, streamlining your project's efficiency and reliability.

‍

dbt Data Quality package

This dbt Data Quality package is a Snowflake only package that helps users access and report on the outputs from dbt source freshness and dbt test results.

dq-tools

The dbt-tools package makes it simple to store and visualize dbt test results in a BI dashboard.

re_data

re_data is an open-source data reliability framework for modern data stack.

_Conclusion

Getting started with dbt testing is simple thanks to the predefined generic dbt tests found within dbt Core and the additional generic tests found in dbt-utils and dbt-expectations. In addition to these juggernauts of the dbt community other organizations in the dbt community have contributed a additional generic tests, tools to improve dbt development, libraries that can help with validation and governance before releasing code to production and tools that can improve data quality observability. If you are using dbt cloud or dbt core you may be interested in reading more about dbt alternatives such as Datacoves which falls under the managed dbt core solutions.